Do you want to know how students feel about their
involvement experience? Do you wonder if
students’ experiences are similar in different organizations? We wondered the same things about involved
students at Texas A&M. But how do
you go about answering these questions on a campus of 50,000 students with
almost 900 student organizations?
We decided to take an approach combining reflection and one
minute papers. We asked advisors to
participate with their student groups to have them complete a series of one
minute papers throughout the academic year.
Students would reflect through these one minute papers each month from
September through April. After advisors
administered the one minute paper, a group of staff members would read each
reflection and score it based on an AAC&U rubric for integrative learning
or lifelong learning.
So, how did it work?
We had almost 1,400 students involved in the project as it
started, and about 1,100 during the spring semester from about 70 different
student organizations throughout the Division of Student Affairs. We were able to capture information from
students in a variety of different roles and groups to learn about our
students. However, it was a lot of work
to get forms back from all advisors each month and we did drop a few groups
early on because they had gotten so far behind in the monthly reflections.
The reflection prompts we gave students each month were:
- What brought you to this particular student
organization and why is it a good fit for you? (September)
- Beyond building friendships and networking, what
do you personally hope to learn through this student involvement experience?
(October)
- What connections, if any, can you make between
this student involvement experience and your classroom experience? What connections, if any, can you make
between this student involvement experience and your career path? (November)
- Based on this student involvement experience,
please give an example of a time when you expressed your views, solutions, or
opinions on an issue. If you have not
expressed your views, solutions, or opinions on an issue, please share your
thoughts on why not. (December/January)
- How does this student involvement impact your
life experience? (February)
- How have you applied skills or abilities gained
from previous experiences to solve problems or explore issues in this student
involvement? (March)
- How do you see yourself now compared to who you
were at the beginning of this student involvement experience? (April)
Would we do anything differently?
While this project was a great initiative looking at a large
number of involved students from across the division, we did learned a LOT. We would spread out the reflections to a
couple times a year, but ask that students spend more than “a minute” on them
to get at some deeper concepts. The
monthly pace was challenging for advisors in administering the one minute
papers and students reflecting on the question asked. We would also plan more staff time for
reading and scoring the reflections and only ask one question per time.
The concept from this project could easily be applied to
individual groups or even during one-one-one meetings with students. There are easy ways to build in reflection
with your students and help them develop the skill to look back at what has
happened in order to look ahead with better clarity and direction.
- Kelly Cox